Submit your review
This is the best flavor by far. I am always excited to make a chocolate peanut butter shake. It's a daily highlight.
This is the best flavor I have tried so far. All have been really good, but this one is five-star excellent! The first thing you taste is the chocolate. It tastes like a really thick, chocolate milkshake. Then you swallow and the aftertaste on the back of your tongue is peanut butter - delicious.
Seriously, WOW! This Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor hits the mark in every category for me. I was hesitant to spend $70 on something I might not like (the sample size had been out of stock for months). I am not a huge fan of chocolate or of peanut butter but I do like them together so I took the chance. Huge score! This Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor is a full flavor that is satisfying from start to finish. It is more filling than the other flavors - so much that I almost forgot to drink my third shake for the day. The other three flavors I have tried all have an underlying flavor that is identical (not a bad flavor, just a true similarity). This one stands out and does not taste the same as the others - it stands out far and above.
I've tried and been pretty unhappy with the strawberry as well as the mocha flavors. However, I LOVE this flavor. I'd drink this just as a desert. I may never buy another flavor again.
I tried this flavor based solely on the reviews here and, man, it's every bit as good as the reviews say! I love chocolate and peanut butter and this flavor is the perfect marriage of the two. It's amazing that I can replace meals with something so delicious!
This is ridiculously good (if you love peanut butter), it tastes like creamy Reese's peanut butter cups. This would be a good one for a dinner replacement, especially if you're craving something dessert-like.
Wow! This is by far the most delicious flavor I have tried. Just like everyone else says.. it tastes like liquid Reese's peanut butter cups. So good! I could easily have had four shakes and still want more.
I'm a huge chocolate peanut butter fan, and this is the flavor for me.Tastes like a Reese's peanut butter cup. I have to stop myself from drinking it too often.The peanut butter flavor is very strong and very real tasting.The only downside is that it's more expensive than the rest of the flavors!
If you love peanut butter you cannot go wrong with this. I like it so much that I even add some PB2 in there for more peanut butter goodness.
You've got to really -- really -- like peanut butter to enjoy this. It's quite strong and unless you're a fanatic, you'll probably find it overpowering. It's not awful by any stretch, just not for me. If you're debating between chocolate and PB, chocolate's a much safer bet.